Top 5 Dinner Party Restaurants In Brooklyn To Host A Memorable Meal


Top 5 Dinner Party Restaurants In Brooklyn To Host A Memorable Meal

Dinner parties are a great way to celebrate an accomplishment milestone or even just gather with friends and family to chat and share stories & laughter over a good meal. Whilst attending these parties is something we all look for, playing the role of a host makes everything different.

The pressure of hosting a dinner party is always more than the joy of attending one. And if you are down that road, you must be nodding your head in a "yes" right now. Also, hosting a dinner party is very different from hosting a brunch or lunch party. These parties need bright shades and bling on the side of friends, good food, and great conversations. Thus, you do not just have to take care of the food, but invitations, checking on the guests, seating arrangements, dinner's theme, menu, and whatnot. Mere listing the tasks makes us feel tired, and you probably must be sailing in the same boat. Thus, we are here to help you accomplish one of the most important tasks in hosting a dinner party- selecting a venue. 

Selecting a restaurant, especially in the busy city of Brooklyn with a buffet of choices to offer, can easily transition into an overwhelming experience. And as you are yourself on the journey of finding a dinner party restaurant in Brooklyn, trust us we know how you feel. Thus, after carefully considering everything required to make a dinner party flavorful and memorable, we have sorted a list of top restaurants in Brooklyn to throw a dinner party. 

As you already have much to prepare for the upcoming events, let's jump straight to our best restaurant choices for hosting a dinner party in Brooklyn. 


A big dinner party concludes with guests from different ethnicities, food choices, and preferences. Thus, to host a successful dinner party, you must choose a restaurant whose menu can satisfy everyone's taste palette. NotaBene fulfills this role very well. The restaurant serves 3 cuisines: Georgian, Italian, and French, with plenty of vegan, vegetarian, and non-vegetarian choices. And no matter which dish you pick from the menu, two things are sure- farm-fresh ingredients and joy of flavors.

The other thing on which the restaurant runs a homerun is its ambiance. The restaurant shares an elegant, sophisticated, and luxe vibe that can cater well to corporate dinners, birthday dinners, proposals, anniversary celebrations, and wedding rehearsals. The seating arrangements and the interiors share a royal vibe and can be a great background for your Insta snaps & Snapchat stories. Also, who doesn't like to click food pictures as soon as it is served? We are sure your dinner party guest list must have at least a person or two with the same interests. Well, no need to worry. The restaurant serves food in a well-presentable manner, which is always photobooth-ready.


On the other fronts, the tables are always decorated nicely, with a large flower vase centered in the middle of every table. The staff is dressed well and carefully listens to every instruction you make. We even witnessed staff members try to calm a 12-18-month-old so the mom could have a few bites peacefully, and we loved the gesture. The restaurant ticked everything we had on our list of finding the best dinner party restaurant in Brooklyn and is our top choice. 

Note: If you want to make things more personal, talk to the owner, David, and he will be happy to change the seating arrangements, add a dance floor, and invite a band to make the dinner party more memorable.

Cuisine Served: Italian, Georgian, & French

Portion Size: Good

Must Try: Gebzhalia, Spaghetti W Shrimps, Acharuli Khachapuri, Eggplant Rolls, & Atlantic Salmon W/ Parm Cheese

Location: 282 Brighton Beach Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11235


Contact Details: Call - 1-718-676-0297

                           Email -

Opening Hours: Sunday to Wednesday: 10 am to 10 pm

                           Friday & Saturday: 10 am to 11 pm

Google Rating: 4.7/5

Reviews: 108

Gage & Tollner


The revolving door and the vintage dining hall of the restaurant set its tone apart from the competition. Thus, if you want to go for a theme dinner party, the restaurant can be a great fortress to choose from. The artwork dressing the restaurant's walls makes it a sight to behold, and thus, your guests won't run out of topics to discuss. Also, if you have a crowd who loves desserts, the donuts here will make them applaud you for your choice of venue.


On the other grounds, the staff at the restaurant is knowledgeable and accommodating. The red and white interior theme sets the right mood for a dinner party, and the restaurant is surely on the expensive side. However, if budget is not an issue for you, you will quite enjoy spending an evening here with friends and family. 

Note: Getting dinner reservations at Gage & Tollner is not easy. Thus, always remember to make bookings as early as possible. Although the restaurant has a bar option with stools and lots of mirrors where you can get an entry easily, it won't work as a great choice for a dinner party.

Cuisine Served: American

Portion Size: Satisfactory

Must Try: Fried Chicken, Creamed Spinach, & Donuts

Location: 372 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, United States

Opening Hours: Monday to Thursday: 5 pm to 10 pm

                           Friday to Sunday: 11:30 am to 10 pm

Google Rating: 4.4/5

Reviews: 646

Also Read: Best Dessert Restaurants Brooklyn: Must Visit For Sweet Tooth People

Michael's of Brooklyn


Who doesn't love Italian? If you want to host a dinner with authentic Italian dishes, Michael's of Brooklyn is your best pick. Most popular for hosting memorable dinner parties, a family has run the restaurant since 1964. Yes, to stay for this long in the business and still be on the top of the charts takes a lot of work, and my friend, this restaurant is known to do it all with precision and elegance. 


While the restaurant has a beautiful ambiance with carpet floors, the flavors served here never fail to make a bold impact on its guests. Also, the restaurant is a great choice if you are trying to go old school with the dinner theme. The staff is always dressed nicely and is warm and welcoming. So, if you have friends with whom you would love to rekindle some old-school memories with scrumptious Italian food, pick this place without any second thoughts.

Note: Weekends are the busiest days at the restaurant. Thus, sometimes you face order delays. However, the food makes up for the delay and tastes good every time. If you are planning a dinner party and want to enjoy some calm time where you can chat with your homes without too much background chaos, we recommend visiting here on weekdays. 

Cuisine Served: Italian

Portion Size: Good

Must Try: Calamari Pasta, Baked Clams, Bread Basket, Michael's Seafood Hot Antipasto, & Lasagna

Location: 2929 Avenue R, Brooklyn, NY 11229, United States

Opening Hours: Tuesday to Sunday: 12 pm to 10 pm

                          Monday: Closed

Google Rating: 4.7/5

Reviews: 1234



Want to host a dinner under the beautiful skyline of NYC? If yes, hosting a dinner at Olmstead Brooklyn will offer you a surreal ambiance to finish the job perfectly. By hearing about the experience, you might be considering the price factor. The good news is the restaurant charges a very fine amount for the experience it is providing. So, by the end of your hosting experience, you may not feel a big hole made inside your pocket. 


Besides the great ambiance here, you can give your guests a creative tasting experience in which every dish is unique and beautifully curated. So, not only is the food served here via Snapchat ready, but it will also provide the guests with new topics to talk about. If you host dinner parties frequently and want to provide a different taste to your guests this time, Olmstead Brooklyn has to be your choice. 

Note: The restaurant is not a good option for people who get easily cold for winter visits because of an open setting. While the restaurant uses heaters, one may feel cold and, thus, won't be able to enjoy the experience fully. 

Cuisine: American

Portion Size: Small

Must Try: King Crab Over Rice with Pea Mint Foam, Duck Liver Mousse, & Butternut Squash Bread 

Location: 659 Vanderbilt Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238, United States

Opening Hours: Wednesday to Friday: 5 pm to 10 pm

                          Saturday & Sunday: 12 pm to 2:30 pm, 5 pm to 10 pm

                          Monday & Tuesday: Closed

Google Rating: 4.5/5

Reviews: 1160

The Little Owl


Presenting a little food wonderland in Brooklyn, The Little Owl is one of the restaurants with a separate fan base in the city. The restaurant is a great pick for those who like to go big on flavors and want to choose between indoor and outdoor dining experiences for up to six guests. So, if you are hosting for a few of your close friends or just your family, The Little Owl can be your hosting fortress. 


The restaurant is a great place to spend quality time with your homies, enjoying big steaks and sharing the finest notes of Mediterranean cuisine. One of the best things about the place is that you will not only be sharing conversations and laughter, but the food, and portion sizes they serve, are great. The menu here is simple and might lack the fancy, but it serves comfort food. So, if you want to host a casual and warm dinner with a cozy and nostalgic ambiance, The Little Owl is where you should make reservations. 

Note: The place is small and cute, and thus, if you are visiting on weekends, it is better to make a reservation in advance. You can make reservations from 4 pm. The crowd here mostly consists of couples on dates or groups of friends who are just here for fun, so it might be a great place to start the night in Brooklyn. Also, the restaurant is among the places where Friends- the show takes its inspiration. 

Cuisine: Mediterranean

Portion Size: Good

Must Try: Chilaquiles, Pork Enchiladas, Mushroom Risotto, and Egg Steak  

Location: 90 Bedford St, New York, NY 10014, United States

Opening Hours: Monday to Friday: 11 am to 10 pm

                          Saturday & Sunday: 9 am to 3 pm, 5 pm to 10 pm

                          Monday & Tuesday: Closed

Google Rating: 4.5/5

Reviews: 976